Nolan's involvement could make his project the frontrunner since the young director's work has been accepted by a fairly wide audience ("Insomnia" made around $67 million in the U.S.). Aronofksy earned critical respect for "Pi" and "Requiem for a Dream," but the dark edge of those films kept most regular moviegoers on the sidelines. That darkness could translate into an excellent "Batman" film, but it remains to be seen if Aronofsky can successfully jump into blockbusters.
Ashley Judd's star power makes "Catwoman" a contender, but the film is in the hands of first-time director Pitof ("Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc"). Pitof's experience as a visual effects supervisor assures that "Catwoman" will look good, but will the story live up to the aesthetics?